Why Is "Something Extraordinary" by Alexis Hall a Must-Read for Romance Fans?

Are you searching for a romance novel that breaks the mold and delivers a fresh, heartfelt story? "Something Extraordinary" by Alexis Hall is not your typical historical romance. This book stands out for its unique characters, unconventional relationships, and deep exploration of love, identity, and friendship. If you want a novel that makes you laugh, think, and maybe even cry, keep reading to discover why "Something Extraordinary" deserves a spot on your reading list.

What Is "Something Extraordinary" About?

"Something Extraordinary" is the third installment in Alexis Hall’s "Something Fabulous" series. The story follows Sir Horley Comewithers (also known as Rufus) and Arabella Tarleton (Belle), two friends who embark on a wild road trip to Gretna Green. Both are trying to escape the expectations of society and their own families. Horley, who is gay, faces pressure to marry a respectable young woman. Belle, who is aromantic and bisexual, has no interest in romance but wants to help her friend avoid a lifetime of misery.

Their journey is packed with chaos, humor, and unexpected encounters, including run-ins with highwaymen, innkeepers, and scorned fiancées. Along the way, they question what marriage, love, and partnership really mean. Can two friends find happiness in a platonic marriage? Or will their feelings for each other—and for others—change everything?

Who Are the Main Characters?

• Sir Horley Comewithers (Rufus): A charming, drama-prone gentleman who is extravagantly gay. He struggles with unrequited love and the pressure to conform to societal norms.

• Arabella Tarleton (Belle): Belle is blunt, witty, and fiercely independent. She is aromantic, meaning she does not experience romantic attraction, but she deeply values friendship and loyalty.

• Supporting Cast: The novel features a colorful array of side characters, including a nervous highwayman named Gil, Belle’s twin brother Bonny, and Valentine, Bonny’s ducal lover. These characters add layers of humor and complexity to the story.

What Makes This Book Different?

Unconventional Romance

Unlike most romance novels, "Something Extraordinary" centers on a marriage of convenience between two people who are not romantically interested in each other. Instead, their relationship is built on trust, support, and a deep platonic love. Both Belle and Horley encourage each other to seek sexual satisfaction and romantic fulfillment outside their marriage, leading to some spicy and unexpected encounters.

Exploration of Identity

The book dives deep into questions of sexuality, self-discovery, and what it means to belong. Belle and Horley both struggle with their identities and how society views them. Their journey is as much about finding themselves as it is about finding happiness together.

Humor and Heart

Alexis Hall is known for witty dialogue and sharp observational humor. The banter between Belle and Horley is fast-paced and often hilarious. At the same time, the novel doesn’t shy away from emotional depth. Readers have praised the book for making them laugh out loud and also bringing them to tears with its gentle, thoughtful moments.

Representation

"Something Extraordinary" offers rare representation for LGBTQIA and aromantic characters in historical romance. Belle’s journey as a bisexual aromantic woman is handled with care, and Horley’s experiences as a gay man are explored with nuance and empathy.

Themes Explored in the Book

• Friendship vs. Romance: The novel challenges the idea that romantic love is the only path to happiness. It shows that friendship can be just as meaningful and fulfilling.

• Self-Acceptance: Both main characters learn to accept themselves and each other, flaws and all. Their growth is central to the story’s emotional impact.

• Societal Expectations: The book critiques the rigid expectations of Regency society, especially around marriage and sexuality. Belle and Horley’s choices highlight the importance of living authentically.

What Do Readers Think?

Readers have called "Something Extraordinary" a fun, chaotic romp with a touch of angst. Many appreciate its fresh take on romance and its willingness to explore unconventional relationships. Some found the pacing a bit slow in the middle, but most agree that the book’s humor, emotional depth, and unique characters make it a standout read.

Here’s what some reviewers had to say:

"This is such a fun adventure that takes a late-act turn into deeply-felt emotions and feelings. It made me feel a million things."
— Smart Bitches, Trashy Books

"This book was absolutely hilarious in its mad cap road trip and so wonderful in the unique and fulfilling relationships that emerge from their adventure."
— Goodreads Reviewer

"What I loved about it was how it expanded the idea of what love is, and what kinds of love are acceptable for couples to have."
— Goodreads Reviewer

Should You Read the Previous Books First?

While "Something Extraordinary" is the third book in the series, you can enjoy it without reading the earlier books. However, if you want to fully appreciate the character arcs and relationships, starting from the beginning will give you more context and emotional payoff.

Where Can You Buy "Something Extraordinary"?

Ready to experience this extraordinary story for yourself? You can purchase "Something Extraordinary" by Alexis Hall from Bookdelico 

Final Thoughts

"Something Extraordinary" is a bold, heartfelt, and hilarious romance that challenges traditional ideas about love and relationships. Alexis Hall’s writing is witty, thoughtful, and emotionally resonant. If you’re looking for a book that offers both laughter and depth, with characters you’ll remember long after the last page, this is the one for you.

Join the Conversation

Have you read "Something Extraordinary"? What did you think about Belle and Horley’s journey? Do you enjoy unconventional romances? Share your thoughts in the comments below—I’d love to hear from you!

Don’t forget to grab your copy from Bookdelico and listen to our podcast for even more bookish discussions. Happy reading, Book Haven friends!