The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny: How Loneliness Shapes Identity and Connection
Share
When Kiran Desai published The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny in 2025, many anticipated a sweeping family saga. What emerges instead is a book haunted by solitude—by the ways in which two people, Sonia and Sunny, carry loneliness with them across continents, relationships, and time. In this novel, loneliness is not just emotional absence; it’s a force that shapes their desires, fractures their relationships, and frames their search for self.
In this post, I want to look closely at how loneliness becomes central to the inner lives of Sonia and Sunny—and how Desai uses setting, narrative structure, and supporting characters to magnify that loneliness. I’ll also touch on how this theme interacts with identity, migration, and the demands of art. (If you’ve not read the novel, I’ll avoid major spoilers.)
From the First Pages: Loneliness as a Backdrop
Before Sonia and Sunny even meet, we’re aware that they come from parallel places of dislocation. Sonia, studying in Vermont, is a young writer yearning for authenticity and influence. Yet she feels alien in that New England setting—different, exposed, unseen. Sunny, on the other hand, is already in New York, adrift, torn between America and India, grappling with expectations from his family and his own desires.
Desai establishes early on that loneliness precedes romance. Meeting isn’t a cure. The two come together already worn by their separate journeys. That setup frames the rest of the novel: their paths will lead them into and out of isolation, but always with loneliness embedded.
Two Solitudes, Two Trajectories
Sonia: The Haunted Artist
Sonia’s loneliness feels existential. She’s haunted by a past intimacy with an older artist, Ilan de Toorjen Foss, who both isolates and seduces her. Critics describe this relationship as controlling, as one that isolates her further from her own voice.
She returns to India after the relationship fails, yet the emotional scars follow her like a ghost dog—a motif in the novel that blends magical realism with psychological truth.
Sonia’s loneliness is not a mere absence of people. It’s a disjuncture between desire and voice. She wants to write stories that matter, but is wary of commodifying her identity, catering to “Orientalist” expectations, or flattening personal truth for an audience’s consumption. Her loneliness is tethered to this tension: expressing a self faithfully amid external pressures.
Sunny: Displaced in Place and Family
Sunny’s loneliness is more external—though not only that. He’s physically in New York, trying to escape the gravitational pull of his mother, Babita, and the tangled web of family obligations in India. His romantic life complicates things further: he dates an American woman even while feeling discomfort about fully belonging in either world.
But loneliness also permeates his relationships back home: political violence, corrupt uncles, and the demand that he uphold expectations. His mother, though domineering, is herself isolated, caught in the shadows of her deceased spouse’s legacy and the ambitions of her children. Through Sunny, Desai probes the loneliness of diaspora: being physically present in one place, but emotionally anchored between multiple geographies.
Narrative Structure: Memory, Interruption, and Distance
Desai doesn’t treat loneliness as a single wave that arrives and recedes. Instead, the narrative is layered, elliptical. Memory, side stories, dream sequences, and shifts in voice interrupt linear progression. The novel moves between India and the U.S., rural towns and urban sprawls, public life and internal monologue.
These structural choices reinforce solitude. Interruptions don’t let us linger in comfort or resolution. We see characters distant from each other — sometimes geographically, sometimes emotionally — and we inhabit multiple small solitudes in the same novel. A side character’s grief, a minor family feud—each becomes its own echo chamber of aloneness.
One of the Booker Prize judges praised the fluency with which Desai slips between “philosophical, comic, earnest, emotional, and uncanny” modes.
That multiplicity allows the novel to show loneliness in many shapes: gothic, surreal, quotidian, familial.
Setting and Place: Terrain of Loneliness
Loneliness is also territorial in this novel. It occupies landscapes. There is the crisp isolation of Vermont. The anonymity of New York City. The crowded, memory-laden streets of Delhi, Allahabad, and smaller Indian towns. Each place brings different forms of loneliness—a New Yorker might feel anonymous, an Indian in diaspora might feel foreign, a small-town inhabitant might feel trapped. Desai uses place to reflect interiority.
Moreover, Desai ties loneliness to national and historical ruptures: Partition, riots, migration. Characters carry inherited grief. The loneliness of a person is never fully separate from the loneliness of their lineage or nation.
In one critic’s words: “Alienated and alone at college … perplexed by the idea of magic realism … the dilemma facing an Indian writer is obeisance to the west’s appetites … and the lure of producing ‘stories cheapened by proliferation’.”
Interpersonal Loneliness: The Paradox of Togetherness
Ironically, characters in The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny can be in relationships, yet still profoundly solitary. Sonia with Ilan, Sunny with his girlfriend—both find that intimacy intensifies isolation instead of dissolving it. The promise of “together” doesn’t always deliver connection.
Even their eventual encounters carry reservation. Their shared history — grandparents once tried to match them — hovers over their meetings, injecting awkwardness and inherited expectation. Their romance refuses to be a cure; instead it becomes a terrain on which loneliness reconfigures itself.
Art, Writing, and Loneliness
Because Sonia is a writer, and Sunny is a journalist, the novel constantly riffs on the relationship between creativity, voice, and loneliness. Sonia wonders whether writing multiple narratives until the truth emerges means every story becomes equivalent, i.e. that singular isolation is impossible to pin down. Her fear is that in the attempt to articulate loneliness—or self—she might lose intimacy or truth.
In the Guardian review, Desai is praised for exploring “modern romance and the emotional toll of continuous reinvention in a globalized world.” Sonia’s loneliness is exacerbated by the struggle to adopt a voice that is not a cliche, not hollow, not “orientalist.” She wants solitude, but not silence.
Sunny, too, experiments with narrative: as a journalist in New York covering global stories, he is simultaneously observer and outsider. His loneliness is sharpened by proximity to stories he cannot fully inhabit. The emotional weight of writing about others underscores his own solitude.
Resolution—or Lack Thereof?
One of the striking qualities of The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny is that it doesn’t rush to heal. Solitude doesn’t disappear. Instead, characters learn to live with it, negotiate it, loosen its grip. Their arcs don’t promise perfect closure but offer glimmers: connection, recognition, occasional release.
As critics have observed, this novel is as much about pursuit as arrival. It’s not a tidy romance, nor a linear bildungsroman. It’s messy, sprawling, haunted. And in that messiness lies its power.
Why This Novel Resonates (Especially Now)
Why does this novel—and its focus on loneliness—feel urgent? In a world where migration, identity, hybridity, and dislocation are increasingly common, The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny gestures to the costs of belonging and displacement. It asks: can we ever truly belong if we carry within us histories, loves, silences?
Grab your copy: here